May 2014 · Taranaki, New Zealand
Hotel night porter asleep alone on duty for 1.75 hours unjustifiably dismissed without medical inquiry
A room attendant and night porter at a hotel in Taranaki, the only staff member on duty overnight with about 44 guests, was found asleep on a couch after kitchen staff could not get into the hotel at 5.40am. She said she had been tired, unwell and had a sore back. The Employment Relations Authority found she was asleep for about 1.75 hours, a serious concern for hotel security, but held the dismissal unjustified because the investigation was compromised and a fair employer would have sought medical evidence first; remedies were cut 40% for her contribution.
Case NZ-retail-01Report an issue