Oct 2003 · New York, United States
Ferry pilot who 'reported to work exhausted' jailed; city loses bid to cap liability after 11 deaths
- Safety
- Legal
- Financial
A city-run passenger ferry in New York hit a concrete maintenance pier at full speed after its assistant captain, who had slept poorly and taken prescription painkillers, lost awareness at the controls; 11 people died and about 70 were injured. The pilot admitted he had been too exhausted to work that day and was jailed, as was the ferry director who failed to enforce a two-pilot rule. Federal courts refused to let the city limit its liability, finding that a second pilot or a reasonable practice for pilot incapacitation would have prevented the disaster, and the city's settlements exceeded $90 million.
Case US-maritime-12Report an issue








